[First Verse]
I can't stay and watch you go
Home with someone else
But I won't let you know
I can't help but think the worst
You probably hate me now
But I hate you first

[Chorus]
Shame on me, mmh-mmh
I let a good one go
Shame on me, mmh-hm
I never should've known
Shame on me
I let a good one go
Shame on me, mmh-hm
Shame on me

[Second Verse]
I can't say what's on my mind
'Cause you're with someone new
And it hurts every time
I can't sleep, Lord knows I've tried
To open up again
But it's too cold outside
[Chorus]
Shame on me, mmh-mmh
I let a good one go
Shame on me, mmh-hm
I never should've known
Shame on me
I let a good one go
Shame on me, mmh-hm
Shame on me