[Verse 1: John Darnielle]
In the morning I looked down
Through the third story window overlooking town
Across the water somewhere
You were sleeping over there

[Chorus]
I couldn't believe it
I couldn't believe it
Not if I saw it with my own eyes
With my own eyes, with my own eyes
With my own eyes, with my own eyes

[Verse 2]
In the morning I looked down
Through the third story window overlooking town
And I saw you
And I knew you saw me too

[Chorus]
I couldn't believe it
I couldn't believe it
Not if I saw it with my own eyes
With my own eyes, with my own eyes
With my own eyes, with my own eyes