[Verse 1]
You're still plain and fickle
Looks like I don't know you
And you don't know me
At all
But your lips taste so simple
Like a spoonful of vanilla-flavored ice cream
My love

[Pre-Chorus]
I know I'm not made of lace
And lace and potpourri
But there's nobody like me

[Chorus]
You're boring
Face it
At your best, you're still basic
You're everything I hate about our youth
I'm lost and hysteric
Anything but generic
Don't ever
Don't ever
Don't you dare ever call me vanilla

[Verse 2]
I'm a mixture of water and bone
Not a clone or a stepping stone
See, I am a lot of things
But I can assure you I'm not what it is they say I am
[Pre-Chorus]
Not lace, not potpourri
(Nobody like me)

[Chorus]
You're boring
Face it
At your best, you're still basic
You're everything I hate about our youth
I'm lost and hysteric
Anything but generic
Don't ever
Don't ever
Don't you dare ever call me vanilla

[Bridge]
So what's the matter, pretty, pretty?
It really is a pity, your flavor of choice
I know that this may be a whisper
But it's just our voice

[Chorus]
You're boring, so just face it
At your best, oh, you're still faceless
You're everything I hate about our youth
I am lost and hysteric
Anything but generic
And I never, I never
I never wanna be called vanilla
No, no
Don't you call me vanilla
No, no, no