[Verse 1]
Believe me, I'm speechless
I wish that I could say those words
You whispered so sweetly
And maybe I'll regret this but I've gotta be honest
'Cause we made a promise, I won't break it now
I wish I could hold you
But how could I be so unfair to lead us to nowhere?
We've both been down that road before
And if this should end us please know that I'm helpless
I've made up my mind

[Chorus]
It's not that I don't care the way that you do
It's just my heart's not ready yet
For somebody new
It's not that I don't feel the feelings you do
It's just my heart's not ready yet
For somebody new

[Verse 2]
If only this started when love was something new to me
I'd never have questioned, rejected what we could have been
But when you've been broken, some wounds remain open
That no one can heal (Cannot heal)
[Chorus]
It's not that I don't care the way that you do
It's just my heart's not ready yet
For somebody new
It's not that I don't feel the feelings you do
It's just my heart's not ready yet
For somebody new

[Chorus Variation]
It's not that I don't feel, the feelings you do
It's just my heart's not ready yet
For somebody new
It's not that I don't care
(It's not that I don't care)
The way that you do
(The way that you do, babe)
Cause when the heart's not ready yet
For something so soon, yeah
It's just my heart's not ready yet
(It ain't ready)
For somebody new