[Verse 1]
I know I may seem shy
And I know you're with that other guy
And I wish I was brave enough to try to tell you how I feel
There's somethin' about the fallin' snow
The Christmas songs on the radio
And the Hallmark movies remindin' me I'm alone, alone, alone

[Pre-Chorus]
But I picture us exchangin' gifts
And holdin' hands on winter trips
I wish that I could tell you all of this

[Chorus]
But I just get too nervous to let you know
So if I get some courage and pull you close
Underneath the mistletoe this Christmas
Could it be our new tradition?

[Verse 2]
I tend to wrap my heart up tight
This pretty paper that I hide behind
Is tearin' all the time because of you, because of you
I see us like I see the lights
Dancin' on the tree at night
I wanna tell you everything that's on my mind
[Chorus]
But I just get too nervous to let you know
So if I get some courage and pull you close
Underneath the mistletoe this Christmas
Could it be our new tradition?
Could it be our new tradition?

[Bridge]
And I wish, I wish, I wish
I could tell you all of this

[Chorus]
But I just get too nervous to let you know
So if I get some courage and pull you close
Underneath the mistletoe this Christmas
Could it be our new tradition?
Could it be our new tradition?
Could it be our new tradition?
Could it be our new tradition?
Could it be our new tradition?

[Outro]
Let's make it our tradition