[Verse 1]
To the one keeping my baby warm
Does she tell you she's still yours?
When you fear what she might choose
Does she promise you won't lose?
To the one sharing my lover's bed
Does the heaviness of words unsaid
Give way to comfort in the night to
Make room for the dreams she dreams beside you?

[Chorus]
What was it that made her think she could have two of everything?
One of you and one of me, forever in the in-between

[Verse 2]
To the one keeping my baby warm
Are you holding out for more?
She lives with one foot out the door
Are you sore, are you unsure?
To the one sharing my lover's bed
Do you hold her when she sleeps?
Does she also call you Baby?
You should know she calls me Baby

[Chorus]
What was it that made her think she could have two of everything?
One of you and one of me, forever in the in-between
[Verse 3]
To the one keeping my baby warm
I'm going to be the biggest thorn
In your side, though I won't try
You deserve a simpler life
To the one sharing my lover's bed
It's not my mission to be cruel
But she don't light up the room
When she's talking about you

[Chorus]
What was it that made her think she could have two of everything?
One of you and one of me, forever in the in-between
What was it that made her think she could have two of everything?
One of you and one of me, forever in the in-between