[Intro: Carly Pearce]
(What if we did? What if we did?)
(What if we did? What if we did?)
(What if we did? What if we did?)
(What if we did? What if we did?)

[Verse 1: Walker Hayes]
Lady, lookin' Heaven sent
I've been starin' ever since you walked in this party
I'm sorry, I'm kinda hesitant
Uh, I ain't usually like this (Like this)
Last person that I dated taught me love was overrated
Kinda afraid of fallin' in it
I've been jaded for a minute or two
But girl, there's somethin' about you

[Chorus: Walker Hayes]
Girl, we probably ain't gonna make it to the mornin' much less
To our last-first kiss and your second-date dress
With a chance of forever
'Cause that only happens never
Nah, we probably ain't gonna make it to the honeymoon suite
Settle down in a house on Beechwood Street
With a porch and a swing and a dog and a couple of kids
But hey, baby, what if we did?
[Post-Chorus: Carly Pearce]
(What if we did? What if we did?)
What if we did? (What if we did? What if we did?)
Oh, what if we did? (What if we did? What if we did?)
(What if we did? What if we did?)

[Verse 3: Walker Hayes & (Carly Pearce), Both]
Don't mean to be cynical, relationships are difficult
Momma told me one condition, love is unconditional
It's a wonder happy ever after really happens at all
(It's a wonder how it happens at all)
But maybe that's what we could have
Maybe one day we'll look back
Call me crazy, baby, maybe this could be the night that we met
When I shook my head and said

[Chorus: Walker Hayes]
Girl, we probably ain't gonna make it to the mornin' much less
To our last-first kiss and your second-date dress
With a chance of forever
'Cause that only happens never
Nah, we probably ain't gonna make it to the honeymoon suite
Settle down in a house on Beechwood Street
With a porch and a swing and a dog and a couple of kids
Hey, baby, what if we did?
[Post-Chorus: Carly Pearce]
(What if we did? What if we did?)
What if we did? (What if we did? What if we did?)
Oh, what if we did? (What if we did? What if we did?)
(What if we did? What if we did?)

[Bridge: Walker Hayes & (Carly Pearce)]
And it would be rad if we did
(It would be rad if we did)
I wouldn't be mad if we did
(I wouldn't be mad if we did)
Would you be glad if we did?
'Cause what if we did?
(What if we did?)
And it would be rad if we did
(It would be rad if we did)
I wouldn't be mad if we did
(I wouldn't be mad if we did)
Would you be glad if we did?
What if we did?
(Oh, what if we did? What if we did?)

[Post-Chorus: Carly Pearce]
(What if we did? What if we did?)
(What if we did? What if we did?)
(What if we did? What if we did?)
(What if we did? What if we did?)
[Outro: Walker Hayes & (Carly Pearce)]
Girl, we probably ain't gonna make it
(What if we did? What if we did?)
We probably ain't gonna make it
(What if we did? What if we did?)
What if we did? (What if we did?)
No, I ain't usually like this
(What if we did? What if we did?)